Tuesday, 28 May 2019

BBC / newspapers and Conservative Party

Today press review starts just like BBC 5.30 news - Daily Mail on Labour and antisemitism then Telegraph on Labour revolt against Corbyn. My guess Telegraph is not the most dangerous source but the pattern seems to be clear.

BBC to host several events for potential Conservative leaders. But will they ask questions most of the UK population would be interested in? @bbcquestiontime has suggested that Farage posters from referendum are "ancient history". What actually happened? What are the links between UKIP and the Conservatives? Newsnight has done a Photoshop job on Corbyn as part of a red scare. @maitlis is obviously bored when Labour explains policy on bringing people together. How much time will she allow if Conservatives make similar claims? @afneil has described @carolecadwalladr as a "crazy cat lady". Why has the BBC ignored her main concerns? As repeated at Hay it is probable that Johnson and Gove knew about security concerns with aspects of the referendum. Will they be asked any questions?

How did the BBC get into this situation? they seem so mixed up in Brexit they cannot report on how it happened. Just my take.

Saturday, 25 May 2019

What to expect from #BBC

Just see Dateline London on BBC News telly. It will be online for a few weeks so no clip to show.

But main points, probably more clips to support this anyway.

News agenda on Brexit set by Daily Telegraph. Janet Daley source of information and Boris explanation.

@StrykerMcGuire ‏ states that UK economy is hurt by Brexit. For the #BBC, @BBCCarrie states that "we have been round this" so no further discussion on the economy. So whatever happens or seems to be happening do not expect any clear statements from BBC. Various views given equal time or balanced by some fairly obscure process that would convince you if you watched BBC all the time ( source @robburl )

Bloomberg is available in the UK. For accurate reporting on the UK could be best to look at media based outside.

Corbyn and Labour not much mentioned. Janet Daley concerned Corbyn both too close to business and also a Marxist. Comments on May judgement in when to seek a comprimise cut  rather short imho. But in general, look for journalists reporting to media based outside the UK for most considered views.

BBC will probably ignore Corbyn most of the time and report mostly on potential Conservative leaders. Probably ok for Telegraph circulation but telly audience may head for the beach.

Just my take.

previously

Tuesday, 21 May 2019

BBC not listening to Corbyn

Hardly news this but needs a note in the blog. There was a Marr interview on Sunday. Two days ago. My take he was clear on second referendum, slight advance towards it as reported by Paul Mason on Twitter. But this was not his main point. More about representing both Leave and Remain Labour voters and uniting the country. ( Also describes as nonsense Marr claims he was tongue-tied in supporting Remain during referendum , more below )

After 8 on Today no mention of this, just Laura Kuenssberg and Nick Robinson on "constructive ambiguity" and "sitting on the fence". So my question is whether Corbyn is reported at all. We will be abble to check this week with most of the evidence still online for a month or so. The original referendum more difficult but there is some content still around.

Overload possibly. The basic narrative becomes clear, I have tweeted asking for links if BBC shows wider range of clips, will check later.

Nonsense claims by Corbyn much the best news angle. The idea that Corbyn did not much during referendum is a myth put about as part of the second leadership election. Supported by BBC at the time.

Also interesting this time around remarks by Alistair Campbell on Jeremy Vine show. Not sure he will vote Labour. What support did he offer Corbyn during the first referendum? We can only guess.

Sunday, 12 May 2019

Observer brings back Blair

Just a note, will come back later. Can we learn from this EU election what happened in the referendum? Observer has plenty of space for  Blair, none for what Corbyn said launching the Labour manifesto.

My memory is that Corbyn did a lot to support Remain in the referendum, not reported.

The general election showed Corbyn reached people who gave up on Labour with Blair policy. Will Farage supporters be reached with more Blair?

More later.

Tuesday, 7 May 2019

Misinformation in Referendum , update possible?

Quote recently from  Jean-Claude Juncker as reported in Guardian online

The then prime minister asked me not to interfere, not to intervene in the referendum campaign.
It was a mistake not to intervene and not to interfere because we would have been the only ones to destroy the lies which were circulated around. I was wrong to be silent at an important moment.

Cameron started out very reluctant to mix it with other Conservatives about facts. He did change tack later.

Did the newspapers and broadcast media do enough to check facts?

The election could well be a time to explore further how we got here.

Monday, 6 May 2019

Guess #4 : BBC too far into Brexit to turn back now

Brexit started as an issue inside the Conservative Party . Fair enough to report it as such. But BBC reporting has continued in this manner, whatever else was happening. They met a lot of Conservatives while negotiating new streams of licence fees so this may have clouded their view.

During referendum, both sides of Conservative argument, not much about Corbyn . My take, other clips evidence links welcome. Very little fact checking. Balance of info from various sources, even when contradictions. No distinction Johnson / Farage so no questions. Clips please if memory wobbly.

After referendum Brexit project seen as national interest. Not much reporting of Remain case. Ever closer to May for lead news announcements.

Trump / Brexit issues reported by Carole Cadwalladr have not been well reported on BBC. Marr invited Isabel Oakeshott to help interview. Andrew Neill has been just a bit rude on Twitter some would say. DG claims there has been an apology but is this so?

My guess the BBC realise previous reporting is open to question, so they hope to carry on with the Brexit project. Government policy is sound, previous case well developed, etc.

Any clips of Steve Hilton during the referendum? As memory serves he was presented as an expert.

Other channels are available. RTE has reporters in Brussels.


Guess #3 : Mail / Sun / Telegraph / Express trend towards fantasy

Thinking about the EU elections as a way to find out about the referendum. What happened? Maybe some story will be recalled. The characters from the previous plot still mostly exist and have similar roles. So maybe some clues.

See previous post for "Fantasy Brexit" as promised, to be delivered by ERG some time later. Also "Brexit in Name Only" the version negotiated by May.

Mail and Express sometimes support May in a patriotic sort of way. Telegraph and Sun more likely to talk of betrayal or going back to Brussels to tell them about changes required, or just crashing out.

My guess is that many people recognise the fantasy element but it helps to sell newspapers, also works well with members of the Conservative Party. So can help future leadership bid unless caught out in government trying to do actual policy.

Complicated during EU elections by Brexit Party. Can it be managed just to help shifts inside the Conservatives without actually wrecking it?

Meanwhile the readers for newspapers are fewer and older, more settled in their ways. Less budget for reporting. So complex explanations about the latest wheeze for damage containment, aka Brexit in name only or how this gets through UK politics / EU negotiations could be a boring story too expensive to cover. Loud opinion might be more probable. Time will tell.

Johnson for Telegraph, Gove for Murdoch both probable staying in Conservatives. Step forward Anne Widdecombe for the Daily Express.