Monday, 6 May 2019

Guess #2 : Guardian supports Lib Dems

Thinking about the EU elections as a way to find out about the referendum. What happened? Maybe some story will be recalled. The characters from the previous plot still mostly exist and have similar roles. So maybe some clues.

Based on results and Twitter, seems that a wide range of views , mostly Remain, turn out to be supporting the Lib Dems. Guardian often seems a mess , various columnists with various views.

But assume Lib Dem.

Then the apparent bias on Corbyn and Labour will not disappoint.

This could also explain falls in circulation. This blog is about newspapers as a business, not just what they publish. Recent advice to Corbyn to forget about Leave voters in North because there are so many Remain voters in the South might reflect a distribution policy. Look out for facts on where the print Guardian is available.

Guess #1 : Media bias against Jeremy Corbyn

Thinking about the EU elections as a way to find out about the referendum. What happened? Maybe some story will be recalled. The characters from the previous plot still mostly exist and have similar roles. So maybe some clues.

Bias against Corbyn started with the first leadership election and may have come from some Labour supporters, not just Conservative newspapers. Lord Mandelson for example has been quoted as wanting a change following a clear election setback. Corbyn was not really in control of Labour during the referendum. Alan Johnson has been quoted since. Mandelson very close to Cameron for policy . The newspapers and broadcast probably influenced by some other than Corbyn circle.

When the polls looked dodgy and Cameron decided to make space for Labour, how was it decided to focus on Gordon Brown, and Lord Darling to share a platform with George Osborne?

Why did Channel 4 block Corbyn from uploading to YouTube a full copy of his appearance on Last Leg? Misleading edits abound btw .

What energy went into preparing the "blame Corbyn" meme for the result? Two heckles were reported by BBC News. Turned out on Twitter info that one was from Portland, one from LibDems. Was there ever any apology? Other info welcome.

Before the second leadership election Hilary Benn was quoted in both Sunday Times and Observer though he denies he had anything to do with it. What happened?

Main question. My memory ( see previous bits of this blog ) Corbyn was active in referendum , but with different arguments to Cameron / Mandelson. Emphasis on worker and consumer rights, environmental standards. Not reported well, who decided about this?

Compare recent speech from Corbyn about uniting the party / country. Media only report "fudge" , they may have a point, but Corbyn should at least be reported in his own words as part of this. Result is a boost for Leave as the Remain case is not heard by the part of the UK that supports Corbyn on other issues.

Sunday, 5 May 2019

Update on this blog ahead of EU elections

This blog should get more frequent during the EU election. I realise there is objection to the expense and it may be a waste of time if Brexit actually happens this year. But it is very interesting to compare with the referendum time when this blog started.

More as it continues, these are just notes.

There seem to be three main options as reported in newspapers. ( shorthand for my bias but keeps the blog together )

"Fantasy Brexit". This is the real thing as the ERG are holding out for. Could not be negotiated but this may not matter. Works well as a betrayal narrative to sell newspapers and build a base for conservative politics.

"Brexit in Name Only" seems to be what May is working on. Some other support for this as well.

"Remain" probably more informed about EU than in 2015

---

Newspapers mostly backing "Fantasy Brexit" - Mail, Sun, Telegraph , Express . BBC seems pro Conservative and has reported Brexit as a Conservative story. After the referendum thay seem to have got more into Brexit as a project so the Remain case has not been well reported.

Mail and Express claim to be less racist than during referendum. ( see previous post ) But support for Brexit Party / Fantasy Brexit continues. No distinction between ERG and Brexit Party most of the time. Sun and Telegraph still very supportive. Times fluctuates a bit and their circulation holds up better. Compared to the referendum it is clear that circulation for fleet Street is way down. But still matters. Twittering still a minority.

Hard info unknown on ages of remain / leave supporters and / or which media they follow. My guess BBC R4 Today /Telegraph dropping away with the youth but look forward to facts emerging over the next few weeks. ( Obviously I listen sometimes but this is a habit )

Nigel Farage on Sophy Ridge, fact check starts here.

Responding to a request on Twitter I sent in my question. Probably a coincidence but my question came up. Sophy Ridge did ask about UKIP and racism, also asked about Oldham. My concern is that so far there seems to be very little questioning of how the new party is different to the old party. Or what Farage has said recently.







(By the way, makes blogging / twittering more interesting even if the connections are in my imagination )

I thought the interview was searching enough for this stage of the EU election. Definitely different to the BBC approach which seems to be more about a platform for Farage views. Not many questions. Maybe I just find a misleading sample when I watch / listen. Clips very welcome for future posts on this blog.

So far most interest in refusal to say where the funding comes from. This may be another connection with UKIP. Or maybe not. Suggest follow @CaroleCadwalladr .

But I have found some links around Oldham story.

Some cut and paste in best blogger style

Mail Online strikes some balance and quotes contrary opinion

Not surprisingly, his comments were met with condemnation in some quarters. Oldham MP Jim McMahon accused him of trying to ‘stoke up tensions and create division’ with his ‘us and them’ rhetoric.
Had Farage been speaking in Britain, instead of playing to an American audience in an area full of Trump supporters, he might well have chosen his words more carefully. He thrives on controversy, but he is no fool. The fact of the matter is there are relatively few ‘black’ faces in Oldham. Only 2,797 — 1.2 per cent of the 219,000 population — were classed as ‘black ’in the 2011 census.

But they go back to a pub firebombing and riot in 2001 and find many issues in the later reports.

The Sun quotes local resident Graham Foulkes whose verdict is that Farage is “playing on people’s fear” to win votes in the European Elections.

"I’m angry that someone who doesn’t know Oldham, who’s only been here once, is stoking up racism … I challenge Farage to come to Oldham and find one street that matches his description. They don’t exist."

The Sun adds that

That’s perhaps not strictly accurate: plenty of areas of Oldham are predominantly Asian or white – like Waterloo Street in the overwhelmingly South Asian area of Glodwick, where colourful fabric shops and stores selling exotic vegetables and spices nestle alongside rows of small terraced housing.

Criticism of Farage is more direct in the Manchester Evening News

Nazir Afzal , former chief prosecutor in Greater Manchester, and now chairman at Rochdale's Hopwood Hall College, said Mr Farage was 'stoking racial tension'.
He said: "I know Oldham very well and this is dangerous scaremongering again from Farage, 'integration' is not 'assimilation'.
"All towns have their problems, but none are improved by him stoking racial tension.

It will be interesting to see if Sophy Ridge takes up the offer to visit Oldham with Farage. Others can comment also.

More stories may come from the USA. Farage has spent some time outside the UK while between parties.




Monday, 29 April 2019

Hard News as interview, comment on Guardian and Daily Express

Today in Guardian, interview about new editor of Daily Express. Very interesting take on immigration and past policy during referendum. Much to come back to when there is more time.

Background, Reach was Trinity Mirror. Printing resource needs more titles as circulation declines. Expect more of this sort of info exchange with Guardian, also printed by Reach. Contract for five years from 2018. Look at a graph and guess on UK total newspaper print requirement in 2023.

Mail is maybe shifted from what it was. Backing May deal on Brexit seen as moderate?

Sun and Telegraph still on the case.

Apparently UKIP is too right wing / racist etc but Brexit Party and Farage gets no critique so far. things may change. Sample story.

Sunday, 28 April 2019

Back to referendum, forward to Trump UK visit

Trying to think more around the story, not just news events. Or the situation, there is no story. Not sure, see blog trying to understand " the coming crisis of cognition" .

Blog has been mostly about Brexit but starts with the newspapers, Fleet Street. They are writing about Trump visit to UK coming up in June. Seems to help explain how the referendum happened. Also events such as Trump election may fit.

Sunday Times reports that Boris Johnson may dine with Trump. How long has this been going on? Breitbart links to Trump and Brexit. Waiting on further study for detail.

Observer background on US / UK diplomacy but not much on the time just after Trump elected. Farage offered to act as a UK envoy. FO upset. As memory serves the State Visit offer was speeded up as catchup. Meanwhile Michael Gove was working as a journalist for Times and got an interview at Trump Tower. Was Murdoch nearby? nobody knows but the #PlanetFox story seems to make sense. Look to the Times / Sun for best guide to Trump moves around UK.

This next bit not very confident about how to back up with evidence, but keeps returning. Brexit case is made in absence of effective messages to the contrary. Labour / Corbyn are doing a job but not reported. This is now, could have been the same in referendum. The "liberal" media don't want to cover this set of interests. Observer today, like Guardian. bashing away on what Corbyn must do re second vote. Almost no reporting on local elections or what Corbyn actually has to say. My take based on this and Twitter is that the Remain case is not going to persuade anyone. It is self indulgent, quite rude. Labour has a complex conversation going on that I think will block Brexit eventually as intended by Conservatives. But not helped by the supposed liberal end of the media. Not a failure of Corbyn, maybe a consequence. Will study this a bit more.

Local election results will be interesting. Labour could do well. TIG not standing, seems they not interested in locality, just a fairly simple pitch at Remain frustration.

This blog about cyberspace as well as Europe. Mostly this means USA media, where cyberspace comes from. Trump / Brexit getting closer to one stream on Twitter. ( Might just be me in one bubble but I think not ) also CNN on cable, much more range than BBC, imho.

Sunday, 14 April 2019

BBC news note

Maybe just one sample but worth a note.

BBC Radio 4 news at 8 this morning leads with anti Corbyn story #1 from Sunday Times on antisemitism and then anti Corbyn story #2 from Observer on second referendum.

My take, there are other racism stories of interest. Corbyn supports conference policy. He prefers a general election. Most people understand this. Few will switch to another party on one issue.

This follows a week in which Farage has had more airtime on BBC than I can remember for any other launch event.

So this blog will have to do more about how broadcast works with newspapers. Even as print circulation declines. Maybe they need them so much they will invent equivalents.

More later.